This is just me speculating in my usual over-imaginitive way:
was Lind Street anywhere near St James Church in Ryde? Digging about, I came upon the history of the church which was, and still is, very evangelical in its stance. It seems possible that proximity to an evangelical church might have been a priority for Capt. B. when choosing a place of worship.
A few years prior to Captain B's arrival, there had been uproar there over their priest, Richard Waldo Sibthorp, who hopped around between Rome and Evangelicalism, and gained mild notoriety. The evangelicals won, and the church remains strongly evangelical to this day.
see
www.churchsociety.org/aboutus/managed/P ... Church.htm
If you have difficulty accessing this link, simply Google St James Church,
I O W and you will find the Church Society link about 9 down in the listings.
There may not be anything more to be gleaned in the church records but if he did worship there, the doctrinal upheavals, in view of JWB's evangelical leanings, might add a little background to his story.
I'll move the relevant threads on JWB from the 'crimping' thread to this thread when I learn how. My two expert advisers are out of contact at the moment.